VO-BB - 20 YEARS OLD!

Neil K. Hess · Posted: Tue Dec 25, 2012 3:51 pm Post subject: Audition vs. Pro Tools

For those of you who have used both pro tools and adobe audition: what do you see as the pros and cons of each?
_________________
http://neilkhessvo.com

Yonie · CM Joined: 31 Aug 2011 Posts: 906

Pro Tools, but only because I started with it. This is such a highly individual preference, and I think many answers have the same basis as mine.

Bill Campbell · DC Joined: 09 Mar 2007 Posts: 621

I prefer AA because of the included processing dynamics and the wide variety of file types available in the software.

You can do fine work in both. If you're trying to decide for yourself, look for a used copy of AA 1.5. You can put it on as many computers as you like with no online registering.
_________________
www.asapaudio.com

cyclometh · Posted: Wed Dec 26, 2012 9:40 am Post subject:

This is a discussion that comes up often. The choice of DAW is a personal one and based on user preference and familiarity.

That said, I'd tend to suggest that if all else is equal to avoid ProTools. The reason is simply because that is a lot of functionality you won't use as a VO, but you will still pay for it (in both cost and learning curve).

I personally use Cubase, which is actually more intended for music production than the kind of work I do, but it's what I learned on and so I'm most comfortable with it.
_________________
Corey "Vox Man" Snow
http://voxman.net

Bish · Posted: Wed Dec 26, 2012 10:34 am Post subject:

I have used both, and I tend to agree with the "general wisdom" that I've gleaned from here and elsewhere. If you have acquired ProTools knowledge and are comfortable with the workflow, then it's a good tool (albeit plagued with version control, dongles and compatibility issues). Lots of people have grow with the industry over a number of years and know how to get the best out of ProTools without getting bogged down in its particular idiosyncrasies. If however, you are coming in cold, with no pre-existing time investment in ProTools, then avoid it like the plague.

Most complex tools require time investment. Personally, I'm invested in Apple's Soundtrack Pro (and to a lesser extent, Logic). I can pretty much make it do whatever I want as a multi-track DAW. I am trying to transfer my knowledge over to Adobe (but it's a slow process). I think if someone were to give me a full ProTools, I'd smile sweetly, thank them, and give it back.
_________________
Bish a.k.a. Bish
Smoke me a kipper... I'll be back for breakfast.
I will not feed the trolls... I will not feed the trolls... I will not feed the trolls... I will not feed the trolls.

Claire Dodin · Club 300 Joined: 15 Feb 2008 Posts: 392 Location: Sunny LA

I've used both and I prefer Audition for two reasons:

-Audition is easier to use for me, I find it an intuitive software. When I don't know how to do something, I can usually find out by trying without opening the manual. Pro-tools on the other hand is rather painful to learn.

-Audition comes with plenty of effects and you can find great free or inexpensive vts plug-ins. Pro-tools comes with nothing and each plug-in is very expensive (a few hundred $). So the cost to do the same thing with both software is way higher with Pro-tools.

But on the Pro-tools pros, most studios use it and I've been asked before to send them the entire session, which I could not do with Audition. However, this doesn't happen often.
_________________
www.clairedodin.com

Jason Huggins · Posted: Wed Dec 26, 2012 12:35 pm Post subject:

I agree with what's being said. Protools is incredibly powerful...if you are a pro at using it. You don't need 99% of its features though. AA is much easier (though extremely powerful and feature rich) to pick up cold. I LOVE the spectral editing view and waveform editor. Those two things got me to switch from Logic Pro (which I purchased at retail) to AA CS6 (which I also purchased at retail). It was worth it for me.

captain54 · Lucky 700 Joined: 30 Jan 2006 Posts: 744 Location: chicago

Bill Roberts · Posted: Thu Dec 27, 2012 1:49 am Post subject:

Adobe Audition…perfect for pounding out auditions when your racing to get out auditions as fast as you can so you don’t end up in audition position number 86! Pro-Tools…perfect for the booked session that can be interfaced with clients that are Source-Connected. The MP3 option takes some time if you feel like entering all the production information into the file, this step added to the file can also place a transparent watermark on the file. I have been using Audition and its predecessor Cool Edit since the mid 90’s, in fact prior to Cool edit, who has ever used “Fast Eddie” the fast editor?. My association with Pro-tools was incidental to the purchase of an mBox2 back in 2005, and I just sold that same mBox2 weeks ago. My decision on what tool will be used is based on the job requirements, how soon did the client need it yesterday?.

To make this long story short...if I were in your position I would take Captian54's advice, jump on eBay and snag an mBox mini with Pro-tools, learn to used it, I upgraded to Pro-tools 10 so I could upgrade my A/D interface to the RME BabyFace. Bells and whistles between the versions for what we do (VO) is really no big difference, but you will be able to sit down with Adobe once you are Pro-tools wise.

Put me down for 50/50, but if I had to pick one...Pro-tools!
_________________
-----
VO-BB Member # 764 (Dec 2009)

Jason Huggins · Posted: Thu Dec 27, 2012 8:57 am Post subject:

Just to be clear with Neil, any DAW can be Source Connected with a client. I'm not saying you said only ProTools could do that...just don't want anyone to think ProTools is necessary for using Source Connect.

Bill Roberts · Posted: Thu Dec 27, 2012 1:47 pm Post subject:

Jason,

Exactly right, I would say that my statement does imply that fact. For me, I do like the session templates that make it easy with the few tracks that are pre set-up.
_________________
-----
VO-BB Member # 764 (Dec 2009)

Rick Riley · Posted: Thu Dec 27, 2012 2:51 pm Post subject:

Pro Tools

Learn what you need to do, to do what you need. Then when you need to do something more, learn what you need to do that as well.

There's two huge benefits that I see using Pro Tools.

1. You'll never have to say, 'I can't do that'.

2. You'll never have to enter one of these discussions again because you'll already know the answer.
_________________
Never do anything you wouldn't want to explain to the Paramedics

www.rickrileyvoice.com

captain54 · Lucky 700 Joined: 30 Jan 2006 Posts: 744 Location: chicago

Being a musician before the move to full time VO dude, I have had an opportunity to try pretty much every DAW software platform that has been on the market, both Mac and PC, going back to the days of Windows 3.1 and MS-DOS, and when Macs were white/beige plastic.. Back then, software was primarily used for MIDI sequencing, and digital audio was not implemented until computers had enough juice to record natively.

After a while, you start to see that the differences in all the platforms are somewhat incidental. Sort of like the feeling when you rent a car. You sit down and get familiar with the dash at first and where all the controls are, but bottom line, you still put the key in and step on the brake and gas, and that never changes.

These types of polls are interesting in a sense, but it really comes down to what each individual artist's needs are. Now.. taking that one step further... What if your needs change? What if you need a more robust platform that has more capability a couple of years down the road as you take on different types of projects?

In my opinion, this is where ProTools shines..Its astonishing to me how aspects of the program I never ever thought I would use, at some point have come into play.. Twisted Wave, Sound Forge, Audition, Logic, Reaper, Soundtrack Pro, Sound Studio, Audacity, etc.. all have certain things they do better than ProTools.. But for a DAW that can handle pretty much anything you can throw at it now, and 5 yrs down the road, ProTools is the way to go.

The big headache with ProTools, again, IMHO, is its persnickety nature with system compatibility.. It does require some diligence in keeping your system up to only which AVID supports. And ProTools on a PC is another issue all together.

For a newbie, I would say find a used Mbox and a copy of Protools on Ebay for cheap.. Then try Sound Forge, Twisted Wave, Audacity, Audition and anything else your heart desires.. I believe all the aforementioned can be used on a free trial basis.. The Mbox will run with all of these programs.. The ProTools online tutorials are tricky because most are geared toward music production/vo production. If you can find someone who knows the program, pay them to sit with you for a couple of hours and get u up and running... Well worth it.

georgethetech · Posted: Fri Dec 28, 2012 12:52 pm Post subject:

Or take a shortcut and get my Pro Tools for VO tutorials from VoiceoverXtra.com

I'd be a wealthier man if I insisted my clients use Pro Tools over TwistedWave, I am convinced of that! But I wouldn't be able to live with myself, either...

The Poll is neck and neck, I'll make it a tie and pick AA.
This might be the next topic banned from discussion, going the way of PC vs Mac.
_________________
If it sounds good, it is good.
George Whittam
GeorgeThe.Tech
424-226-8528
VOBS.TV Co-host
TheProAudioSuite.com Co-host
TriBooth.com Co-founder

Jason Huggins · Posted: Fri Dec 28, 2012 3:23 pm Post subject:

I was wondering if this was one of those topics. It is so subjective and personal that there is not an answer. It's kinda like asking, "Which mic is best for VO?" Well....not quite that subjective and personal, but certain things are more important to certain people than other things.

One thing to note (as a huge difference between AA and PT) is that PT is a FULL-FEATURED DAW, and AA is really a wave editor for production. AA wasn't designed to be a music production tool, but it IS designed to do what we VOs need it to do very well. I say, get the demo of each, mess around with both. (Note: You will need an iLok key for the PT demo...but you'll need it someday anyway, $50 at Guitar Center) Figure out which one feeds your creative side, and which one "gets out of your way" the most when you are using it. For me, AA, for others PT, for others neither. Just figure out what works for you and use it!